Appointment setting for commercial insurance agencies, compared by Maxionlabs
Best appointment setting companies for commercial insurance agencies (2026)
If you write commercial lines and want qualified appointments with a public price and a written meeting definition, pick Maxionlabs, if you want a phone team plus inbound marketing from one vendor, Abstrakt, if you want phone volume month to month with no-shows rebooked, CFE Marketing, and if you write personal lines, life or health, InsureLeads or EverQuote. Plans are sized to your agency: the standard is 15 qualified appointments a month, with smaller starting plans and plans built around fewer, larger accounts.
Updated 2026-11-21
Six providers, six things you can check
| Compare on | Commercial insurance focus | Published price | Written meeting definition | No-show policy | Guarantee | Contract |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maxionlabs | Yes. Commercial P&C and benefits agencies onlyOutsourced outbound agency, email | Standard 4,725 USD/mo for 15, smaller and custom plans | Yes, four checks in writing on our pricing page | Yes. A no-show does not count and is replaced | $315 credit per missed appointment, unused credit paid back in cash when you cancel | Month to month |
| Abstrakt Marketing Group | Partly. One commercial insurance page among trades and B2B industriesPhone BDR team, plus website and content | From $5,000 a month (Outbound BDR), $6,500 bundled with inbound and content | Yes, on its commercial insurance page | Not published | Appointment number agreed in writing. Missed by year end, they work free until they hit it | Not published for Outbound BDR. A one-year agreement is named for the inbound add-on |
| CFE Marketing | Partly. A commercial insurance page, priority audiences are tech, manufacturing, SaaS and solarPhone and email SDR team | Not published, custom per project | Yes. BANT, plus premium size, lines, renewal timing and decision authority | Yes. No-shows rebooked at no extra cost | None published | One month pilot, then month to month, 30 days notice |
| LeadSureX | Yes. Commercial lines onlyPhone setting team, or single appointments | Not published, priced per appointment on premium, headcount and complexity | Yes. Decision maker or influencer confirmed, renewal window verified | Yes. Under 7 of the first 10 show, 5 more free | The show-rate offer above. Its terms page guarantees no appointment count | Not published, set in a written engagement |
| InsureLeads (getinsureleads.com) | No. Final expense, Medicare, health, life, auto, home and annuity, plus commercial truckLeads, live transfers, preset appointments | Setter seat from $2,500 a month. Preset appointments $150 to $575 by line | Partly. "Kept" means the prospect attends or completes a phone consultation | Yes. Confirmed presets get one free rebooking, kept presets billed only when held | Invalid leads replaced. No appointment count on a setter seat | Month to month |
| EverQuote | No. Consumer insurance shoppers, each lead to up to three agentsConsumer shopper leads and calls | Not published | No. Sells leads and calls, not meetings | Not published | None published | Not published |
What each one puts in writing
Where another provider fits better
| Compare on | Look at |
|---|---|
| You want a phone team in your name, plus website and SEO, from one vendor | Abstrakt Marketing Group |
| You have several producers and want phone volume, month to month | CFE Marketing |
| You want to buy commercial appointments one at a time | LeadSureX |
| You write final expense, Medicare, health or life | InsureLeads |
| You write personal lines and want shopper leads in your ZIP codes | EverQuote |
| You write commercial P&C or benefits and want a fixed monthly count with cash back on a miss | Maxionlabs |
New to this? Start with how commercial insurance appointment setting works and why bought commercial leads disappoint.
How we scored this
Maxionlabs wrote this page and is one of the six. Every competitor cell comes from that competitor's own site, read 2026-11-21, linked below. Ours comes from the Maxionlabs pricing page. No scores, no ranking. The longer read on one rival is Maxionlabs and Abstrakt compared.
Something changed on your site? Corrections to maksym@maxionlabs.com.
Questions owners ask
- How much does insurance appointment setting cost?
- Three of the six publish a price as of 2026-11-21. Maxionlabs is $4,725 a month for 15 qualified appointments as standard, with smaller and custom plans. Abstrakt starts at $5,000 a month. InsureLeads sells preset appointments at $150 to $575 and setter seats from $2,500 a month. CFE Marketing, LeadSureX and EverQuote quote on a call.
- What counts as a qualified appointment?
- At Maxionlabs, four things in writing. Your counties and carriers, above your floor of $25,000 in premium or 20 lives, a need inside 3 months, and the owner in the room. Abstrakt, CFE Marketing and LeadSureX publish similar tests. Get yours in writing before you sign.
- What happens if an appointment is a no-show?
- At Maxionlabs a no-show does not count and is replaced, and every appointment short of 15 is $315 back. CFE Marketing rebooks no-shows. LeadSureX adds 5 free if fewer than 7 of your first 10 show. Abstrakt and EverQuote do not publish a no-show policy.
- Do I have to sign a long contract?
- Maxionlabs, InsureLeads and CFE Marketing run month to month, CFE after a one month pilot with 30 days notice. Abstrakt, LeadSureX and EverQuote do not publish their term, so ask before you sign.
Sources
- Maxionlabs pricing: price, the four checks, no-show and credit terms (read 2026-11-21)
- Abstrakt Marketing Group, Outbound BDR pricing (read 2026-11-21)
- Abstrakt Marketing Group, commercial insurance page and qualified definition (read 2026-11-21)
- CFE Marketing Services, homepage: no-shows rebooked, month to month (read 2026-11-21)
- CFE Marketing Services, commercial insurance page (read 2026-11-21)
- CFE Marketing Services, pricing: custom per project, 30 days notice (read 2026-11-21)
- LeadSureX, homepage: commercial lines only (read 2026-11-21)
- LeadSureX, for agencies: 70% show-rate guarantee (read 2026-11-21)
- LeadSureX, for agents: per-appointment pricing and qualification (read 2026-11-21)
- LeadSureX, terms: no guarantee of appointment counts (read 2026-11-21)
- InsureLeads, insurance appointment setting: seat and preset prices, no-show terms (read 2026-11-21)
- InsureLeads, pricing: preset appointments by line, confirmed and kept defined (read 2026-11-21)
- InsureLeads, FAQs: verticals, minimums, month to month (read 2026-11-21)
- InsureLeads, lead replacement policy (read 2026-11-21)
- EverQuote for Agents: lead sources, up to three agents per lead (read 2026-11-21)
See what this looks like for your agency.
Book a 20 minute call with Max