Skip to main content

For owners of commercial P&C and benefits agencies with 2 or more producers. Not for solo agents or personal lines shops.

Are commercial insurance leads worth it? Depends who is going to work them

If you're a producer who can call a lead within minutes of it landing, some are, judged on cost per bound account and never on price per lead. If you're an owner with 2 or more producers and nobody prospecting, mostly no. A lead is a name that still needs the call. The who-works-it test, who, by name, works this lead in the first 5 minutes? Six ways below, every price sourced.

Updated 2026-11-16

A lead is a name somebody in your shop still has to call

A shared commercial lead lands on a Tuesday, like a landscaper with 6 trucks asking for a quote. Who in your shop calls him in the next 5 minutes? In most agencies I talk to at $2M to $15M, nobody.

“We have a system that we could identify who we want to write business with, but we don't have anybody to make the phone calls and make the appointments for us.”

President, commercial P&C agency, Pennsylvania
A name or a conversationTwo halves. On the left, four cards stacked and labelled shared web lead, exclusive lead, aged lead and X-date list, under the heading a name. Next to them a telephone sits on a desk with nobody holding it, labelled somebody still has to dial. On the right, under the heading a conversation, two stick figures face each other, labelled live transfer, referral, qualified sales meeting. A line below reads the dial is the part nobody owns.a nameshared web leadexclusive leadaged leadX-date listnobody holding itsomebody still has to diala conversationlive transferreferralqualified sales meetingalready talkingthe dialthe dial is the part nobody in the building owns
Every lead source is one of two things. A name somebody in your shop still has to dial, or a conversation somebody already set up. Most agencies are short of the dial, not the name.

Judge a lead on cost per bound account, never on price per lead

Price per lead is the number vendors print because it looks small.

A $20 shared web lead binding 1 in 40 is $800 per bound account, on a $4,000 BOP about $480 in year one at 12%. A $315 qualified sales meeting binding 1 in 5 is $1,575 per bound account, above a $25,000 premium floor about $3,000 a year at 12%, gross, and it renews.

Cost per bound account, two rowsTwo rows as an illustration. Top row, a shared lead at $20 binds 1 in 40, so $800 per bound account, and the small bar beside it reads $480 a year, a $4,000 BOP. Bottom row, a sales meeting at $315 binds 1 in 5, so $1,575 per bound account, and the tall bar beside it reads $3,000 a year, a $25,000 account. The cost per bound account is about double on the bottom row and the commission is about 6 times.shared lead$20binds1 in 40per bound account$800$480 a yeara $4,000 BOPsales meeting$315binds1 in 5per bound account$1,575$3,000 a yeara $25,000 account12% commission, gross, year one. Your numbers will differ.
Cost per bound account, as an illustration. A $20 shared lead binding 1 in 40 is $800 per bound account and about $480 a year on a $4,000 BOP. A $315 qualified sales meeting binding 1 in 5 is $1,575 per bound account and about $3,000 a year on a $25,000 account.

About double per bound account, about 6 times the account. And who decided this was a prospect, a form at 11pm, a vendor's filter, or a person who asked about premium and renewal first?

Commercial insurance lead generation, six ways side by side

Read the “who qualifies it” column first, it predicts the rest.

Sources at the end. Hiring a producer is on the producer-or-meetings page.

Six sources of new commercial business, prices as published in the sources.
Compare onExclusivityContact rateWho qualifies itTypical price (sourced)What you own after
Shared web leadsUp to 3 agents at once (EverQuote).Minutes, or it’s gone.The buyer, by filling in a form.$10 to $45 (ActiveProspect). Workers comp form $12 to $30 (Phonexa).The name. The other agents have it too.
Exclusive leadsYours from that vendor. The buyer can still fill in 3 forms.Better. Still a form waiting for a callback.The buyer, plus the vendor’s filters.$45 to $120, up to $200 or more in commercial (ActiveProspect).The name and your notes.
Aged leads and X-date listsNobody’s. Every agent who pays gets the file.Low. Old numbers, changed contacts.Nobody. It’s data.$0.50 to $15 a name, aged (ActiveProspect).The file.
Live transfers and pay-per-callThe call is yours. The buyer may be on his third that day.Near 100%. You pay per accepted transfer.The vendor’s callers, to a script and a count.$30 to $120 live transfer, $40 to $100 pay-per-call (Phonexa).One conversation, often a quote request.
ReferralsYours alone.Near 100%. They were expecting you.The referrer, who knows both of you.No cash. Lunches and favours.The account. You can’t order more.
Qualified sales meetings (Maxionlabs)Yours. Never resold to another agency.Held live with the owner. A no-show is replaced.A person, against a written definition. Floor, appetite, timing, decider.$4,725 a month for 15 meetings, about $315 each.The meeting, the brief, the account, the map of your territory.

Shared and exclusive web leads suit a producer with a phone

Somebody typed the words at 11pm and the form is in your inbox 90 seconds later.

Intent you didn't create, at a price a producer can put on a card. EverQuote publishes the rule, a maximum of 3 agents per lead.

“if you call somebody and they say, yeah, I got five people shopping this, you can be number six.”

President, commercial P&C agency, Pennsylvania, on the leads he bought
One form, 3 agents, same minuteOne business owner stands on the right holding a phone, labelled 1 owner, 1 form, 11pm. On the left three stick figures labelled agent 1, agent 2 and agent 3 each have an arrow running to the owner. The arrows arrive at the same point. A line underneath reads EverQuote sells each lead to a maximum of 3 agents, and the first to dial usually wins.agent 1agent 2agent 31 owner, 1 form, 11pmsame minuteEverQuote: a maximum of 3 agents per leadthe first to dial usually wins
A shared web lead, drawn. 1 owner fills in 1 form at 11pm and 3 agents get it in the same minute. EverQuote's rule is a maximum of 3 agents per lead, and the first to dial usually wins.

Exclusive fixes the vendor side at 2 to 4 times the price, $45 to $120 against $10 to $45 on ActiveProspect's list, and the buyer can still fill in 3 forms in one evening.

Aged leads and X-date lists are the cheapest names you can buy

Aged leads are web leads that didn't sell fresh, resold at $0.50 to $15 a name. X-date lists are the renewal dates for every business in a county, and most owners already pull one. Cost per name is pennies, cost per bound account is almost all wages.

The list on the shelfA spreadsheet labelled last quarter's X-date list sits on a shelf with a few dust marks over it. Below, an empty chair at a desk with a telephone, labelled the seat that works it. To the right, three columns of marks read 100 dials, 3 will talk, 1 is in window. The line underneath reads a list only works if somebody works it.last quarter's X-date listthe seat that works itwhat working it takes100 dials3 will talk1 is in windowa list only works if somebody works itno seat, and the cheapest list is the dearest thing you bought
The list most owners already own. Last quarter's X-date list on a shelf, an empty seat under it, and what working it takes, about 100 dials to find the 3 who'll talk and the 1 in window.

With a caller on payroll a list is the cheapest fuel there is, without one it's the dearest thing on this page. We don't sell lists and we don't dial X-date files.

Live transfers and per-appointment vendors sell you a conversation

A call centre dials a list, gets a business owner to say sure, put me through, and hands you the line, $30 to $120 a commercial live transfer on Phonexa. It fixes the dialing, and the fastest way to a caller's count is a quote request from anyone who'll take one.

Randy Schwantz said it in Insurance Journal in 2018, hourly callers, yeses from people who “would entertain a quote from anyone”, and even at a 50% close a sale cost about $1,000.

“They would charge us $50 for a confirmed appointment... the appointment basically wasn't legit... the prospect's contact just wanted to get them off the phone.”

Executive VP, six-producer commercial P&C agency, Arizona

The unit was wrong. Put in writing what counts as a commercial insurance appointment, a business above your floor, in its renewal window, with the person who signs, or the count gets met with whoever picked up.

Where Maxionlabs fits, and who this page is right for

We map every business in your territory above your floor, usually $25,000 in premium or 20 enrolled lives, reach the owners by email, confirm fit and timing, and the sales meeting goes on your producer's calendar with a brief.

$4,725 a month, month to month, cancel any month, no share of your commission. 15 qualified sales meetings a month, held live, 12 in month one while we ramp. A no-show doesn't count, we replace it. $315 back for every meeting we miss, your counties locked, full terms on the pricing page.

Over 3 months that's 42 qualified sales meetings, close 1 in 5 for about 8 bound accounts, about $25,000 of gross commission a year before producer pay, against $14,175 month to month. An illustration, your book will differ.

42 qualified sales meetings in 3 months to about 8 bound accountsOn the left, 42 small circles in six rows, labelled 42 qualified sales meetings in 3 months. An arrow runs into a funnel labelled close 1 in 5. Out of the funnel come 8 filled circles labelled about 8 bound accounts. Below them a box reads about $25,000 commission a year, a book that renews. A smaller box reads $14,175 paid for the 3 months.42 qualified sales meetingsin 3 months, held liveclose 1 in 5about 8 bound accountsabout $25,000 commission a yeara book that renews$14,175 for 3 months
Three months, drawn as an illustration. 42 qualified sales meetings, your producers close 1 in 5, so about 8 bound accounts and about $25,000 of gross commission a year, a book that renews, against $14,175 paid for the 3 months.

Producers already full is a hire, I'll say so. Not sure which you are? Run the who-works-it test on last month's leads, book a call and bring the answer.

Questions owners ask

Are commercial insurance leads worth it?
For a producer who can call them within minutes, some are, judged on cost per bound account. For an owner whose producers aren't prospecting, mostly not, a lead is a name that still needs the call.
How much do commercial insurance leads cost?
Phonexa’s 2026 list puts a shared workers comp web lead at $12 to $30 and a commercial live transfer at $30 to $120. ActiveProspect lists shared at $10 to $45, exclusive at $45 to $120 and aged at $0.50 to $15. Nobody publishes cost per bound commercial account.
What is the difference between shared and exclusive insurance leads?
A shared lead goes to up to 3 agents at once in EverQuote’s case, so you’re racing to the phone. An exclusive lead is sold to you alone by that vendor, at 2 to 4 times the price, and the buyer can still fill in 3 forms.
How do I get commercial insurance leads for my agency?
Shared web leads, exclusive leads, aged or X-date lists, live transfers, referrals, and qualified sales meetings. Pick by who’s going to make the call.
What does a commercial insurance lead generation agency actually do?
One of three things. Sells you a list, sells you a lead or a live transfer, or holds a sales meeting for you. That’s the whole difference in what you pay for, a name, one conversation, or an owner who already said yes.

Sources

  1. Phonexa, "Insurance Leads Cost: Complete Pricing Breakdown", 31 March 2026: web form workers comp shared $12 to $30, web form commercial insurance seasonal $5 to $30, pay-per-call commercial insurance $40 to $100, live transfer commercial insurance $30 to $120
  2. ActiveProspect, "Insurance leads cost", 28 September 2026: shared web leads $10 to $45, exclusive web leads $45 to $120, live transfer leads $80 to $200+, aged leads $0.50 to $15, "$200 or more for certain exclusive commercial insurance opportunities"
  3. EverQuote Pro: each lead delivered in real time "to a maximum of three agents"
  4. Insurance Journal, Randy Schwantz, "Should You Hire an Appointment Setter?", 17 December 2018: "the cost of a sale becomes $1,000 each" at a 50% close; low-cost telemarketing firms hire hourly callers and the only people who respond "would entertain a quote from anyone"
  5. Maxionlabs, published price and terms: $4,725 a month, 15 qualified sales meetings held live, $315 back per miss

See what this looks like for your agency.

Book a 20 minute call with Max