# Best appointment setting companies for commercial insurance agencies (2026)

If you write commercial lines and want qualified appointments with a public price and a written meeting definition, pick Maxionlabs, if you want a phone team plus inbound marketing from one vendor, Abstrakt, if you want phone volume month to month with no-shows rebooked, CFE Marketing, and if you write personal lines, life or health, InsureLeads or EverQuote. Plans are sized to your agency: the standard is 15 qualified appointments a month, with smaller starting plans and plans built around fewer, larger accounts.

Updated 2026-11-21

## Six providers, six things you can check

*Each competitor cell from their own website, read 2026-11-21. "Not published" means we could not find it on their public pages, so ask them.*

| Compare on | Commercial insurance focus | Published price | Written meeting definition | No-show policy | Guarantee | Contract |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Maxionlabs | Yes. Commercial P&C and benefits agencies onlyOutsourced outbound agency, email | Standard 4,725 USD/mo for 15, smaller and custom plans | Yes, four checks in writing on [our pricing page](https://www.maxionlabs.com/pricing#qualified) | Yes. A no-show does not count and is replaced | $315 credit per missed appointment, unused credit paid back in cash when you cancel | Month to month |
| Abstrakt Marketing Group | Partly. One commercial insurance page among trades and B2B industriesPhone BDR team, plus website and content | From $5,000 a month (Outbound BDR), $6,500 bundled with inbound and content | Yes, on its commercial insurance page | Not published | Appointment number agreed in writing. Missed by year end, they work free until they hit it | Not published for Outbound BDR. A one-year agreement is named for the inbound add-on |
| CFE Marketing | Partly. A commercial insurance page, priority audiences are tech, manufacturing, SaaS and solarPhone and email SDR team | Not published, custom per project | Yes. BANT, plus premium size, lines, renewal timing and decision authority | Yes. No-shows rebooked at no extra cost | None published | One month pilot, then month to month, 30 days notice |
| LeadSureX | Yes. Commercial lines onlyPhone setting team, or single appointments | Not published, priced per appointment on premium, headcount and complexity | Yes. Decision maker or influencer confirmed, renewal window verified | Yes. Under 7 of the first 10 show, 5 more free | The show-rate offer above. Its terms page guarantees no appointment count | Not published, set in a written engagement |
| InsureLeads (getinsureleads.com) | No. Final expense, Medicare, health, life, auto, home and annuity, plus commercial truckLeads, live transfers, preset appointments | Setter seat from $2,500 a month. Preset appointments $150 to $575 by line | Partly. "Kept" means the prospect attends or completes a phone consultation | Yes. Confirmed presets get one free rebooking, kept presets billed only when held | Invalid leads replaced. No appointment count on a setter seat | Month to month |
| EverQuote | No. Consumer insurance shoppers, each lead to up to three agentsConsumer shopper leads and calls | Not published | No. Sells leads and calls, not meetings | Not published | None published | Not published |

## What each one puts in writing

*Full dot, it is on their website. Half dot, partly. Empty ring, not published. Only Maxionlabs publishes all four. Everything else is a question for their sales call.*

## Where another provider fits better

*Pick by buyer, not a ranking.*

| Compare on | Look at |
| --- | --- |
| You want a phone team in your name, plus website and SEO, from one vendor | Abstrakt Marketing Group |
| You have several producers and want phone volume, month to month | CFE Marketing |
| You want to buy commercial appointments one at a time | LeadSureX |
| You write final expense, Medicare, health or life | InsureLeads |
| You write personal lines and want shopper leads in your ZIP codes | EverQuote |
| You write commercial P&C or benefits and want a fixed monthly count with cash back on a miss | Maxionlabs |

New to this? Start with [how commercial insurance appointment setting works](https://www.maxionlabs.com/commercial-insurance-appointment-setting) and [why bought commercial leads disappoint](https://www.maxionlabs.com/commercial-insurance-leads).

## How we scored this

Maxionlabs wrote this page and is one of the six. Every competitor cell comes from that competitor's own site, read 2026-11-21, linked below. Ours comes from [the Maxionlabs pricing page](https://www.maxionlabs.com/pricing). No scores, no ranking. The longer read on one rival is [Maxionlabs and Abstrakt compared](https://www.maxionlabs.com/abstrakt-alternative).

Something changed on your site? Corrections to maksym@maxionlabs.com.

## Questions owners ask

### How much does insurance appointment setting cost?

Three of the six publish a price as of 2026-11-21. Maxionlabs is $4,725 a month for 15 qualified appointments as standard, with smaller and custom plans. Abstrakt starts at $5,000 a month. InsureLeads sells preset appointments at $150 to $575 and setter seats from $2,500 a month. CFE Marketing, LeadSureX and EverQuote quote on a call.

### What counts as a qualified appointment?

At Maxionlabs, four things in writing. Your counties and carriers, above your floor of $25,000 in premium or 20 lives, a need inside 3 months, and the owner in the room. Abstrakt, CFE Marketing and LeadSureX publish similar tests. Get yours in writing before you sign.

### What happens if an appointment is a no-show?

At Maxionlabs a no-show does not count and is replaced, and every appointment short of 15 is $315 back. CFE Marketing rebooks no-shows. LeadSureX adds 5 free if fewer than 7 of your first 10 show. Abstrakt and EverQuote do not publish a no-show policy.

### Do I have to sign a long contract?

Maxionlabs, InsureLeads and CFE Marketing run month to month, CFE after a one month pilot with 30 days notice. Abstrakt, LeadSureX and EverQuote do not publish their term, so ask before you sign.

Sources

1. [Maxionlabs pricing: price, the four checks, no-show and credit terms (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.maxionlabs.com/pricing)
2. [Abstrakt Marketing Group, Outbound BDR pricing (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.abstraktmg.com/outbound-bdr/)
3. [Abstrakt Marketing Group, commercial insurance page and qualified definition (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.abstraktmg.com/industries/commercial-insurance-lead-generation/)
4. [CFE Marketing Services, homepage: no-shows rebooked, month to month (read 2026-11-21)](https://cfemarketingservices.com/)
5. [CFE Marketing Services, commercial insurance page (read 2026-11-21)](https://cfemarketingservices.com/leads/commercial-insurance)
6. [CFE Marketing Services, pricing: custom per project, 30 days notice (read 2026-11-21)](https://cfemarketingservices.com/outsourced-sdr-pricing)
7. [LeadSureX, homepage: commercial lines only (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.leadsurex.com/)
8. [LeadSureX, for agencies: 70% show-rate guarantee (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.leadsurex.com/for-agencies)
9. [LeadSureX, for agents: per-appointment pricing and qualification (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.leadsurex.com/for-agents)
10. [LeadSureX, terms: no guarantee of appointment counts (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.leadsurex.com/terms)
11. [InsureLeads, insurance appointment setting: seat and preset prices, no-show terms (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.getinsureleads.com/insurance-appointment-setting)
12. [InsureLeads, pricing: preset appointments by line, confirmed and kept defined (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.getinsureleads.com/pricing)
13. [InsureLeads, FAQs: verticals, minimums, month to month (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.getinsureleads.com/faqs)
14. [InsureLeads, lead replacement policy (read 2026-11-21)](https://www.getinsureleads.com/lead-replacement-policy)
15. [EverQuote for Agents: lead sources, up to three agents per lead (read 2026-11-21)](https://go.everquote.com/pro)

See what this looks like for your agency.

[Book a 20 minute call with Max](https://www.maxionlabs.com/#book-call)
